Page errors occur when browsers, search engines and LLM crawlers cannot access a webpage, usually due to issues like missing pages, broken redirects, or server failures. These errors harm SEO by wasting crawl budget, breaking user journeys, and reducing link equity. Identifying and fixing them quickly helps protect rankings and site performance.

Preread

  • This post does not contain all HTTP status codes and only contains the ones affecting SEO and GEO. For a full list, see this.
  • This guide is ideal for business owners and marketing managers, who would like a deeper understanding of their impact.
  • Remember: no website is perfect, not even this one. Learn, gauge impact and take informed decisions.

Meaning

Page errors occur when a browser (human), search engine or LLM (ChatGPT, Gemini, etc) crawler cannot properly access a webpage, indicated by HTTP status codes. They primarily fall into:

  • 3xx redirection: not technically an error, just a response code.
  • 4xx client-side errors: page not found, bad requests, access denied
  • 5xx server-side errors: server crashes, overloads, or misconfigurations

Search engines closely monitor these errors because they affect user experience and site reliability. Excessive errors translate to lower rankings and crawling inefficiencies. There is also very little public information as to how much monitoring LLMs do internally for page errors and its impact on their crawls.

Common Errors

404 – Page Not Found

  • Cause(s): Deleted/moved pages, broken links, typos
  • SEO Impact: Disrupts crawl paths, dead ends users, reduces link equity
  • Fix: Use 301 redirects, fix links, recreate important pages, custom 404 page (See this amazing article by Atlassian on 44 incredible 404 error pages)

301/302/307/308 – Not an error but notification of redirection (temporary or permanent)

  • Cause(s): When a page is redirected to another page either on the same website or different website.
  • SEO Impact: Poor user experience (UX), slows crawling, link equity leakage, search engines do not crawl redirected URLs.
  • Fix: Use single-step 301 redirects, audit chains, update internal links, audit your backlinks and request an update, keep an internal doc and remove any redirects older than one year.

500 – Internal Server Error

  • Cause(s): Server misconfiguration, faulty code/plugins, CMS errors
  • SEO Impact: Blocks users and crawlers, risks deindexing, signals instability
  • Fix: Check logs, disable recent plugins, restore backups, consult your web host

503 – Service Unavailable

  • Cause(s): Server overload, maintenance, hosting limits
  • SEO Impact: Temporary 503s okay, prolonged leads to crawl delays and ranking drop
  • Fix: Scale servers, use “Retry-After” header, improve hosting

403 – Forbidden

  • Cause(s): Permissions issues, IP blocks, firewall rules
  • SEO Impact: Prevents crawling, blocks pages from index
  • Fix: Fix permissions, update firewall, whitelist crawlers (if you are unsure, see this awesome article by Cloudflare)

410 – Gone

  • Cause(s): Indicates intentional removal of a page
  • SEO Impact: Removes pages from search engine indexes faster than 404
  • Fix: If intentional, no fix is needed. If not, setup a redirect before crawlers take note.

Impact on SEO/GEO

Here is how your SEO & GEO performance can be affected by page errors:

  • Loss of Crawl Budget: Crawlers waste limited crawl time on errors, delaying discovery of new/updated pages.
  • Decline in User Experience: Broken pages frustrate visitors, increasing bounce rates and reduce engagement. User engagement is a very strong SEO signal, if this is of more interest to you, read this. Want to learn how to monitor UX, read this and setup Microsoft Clarity.
  • Deindexing: Extended errors cause pages or site sections to be dropped from search results.
  • Loss of Link Equity: Backlinked pages returning errors fail to pass authority, harming rankings sitewide.

Ecommerce vs Other Websites

While page errors impact all websites, their effects and management strategies can differ significantly depending on the type of site.

Let’s explore how page errors affect eCommerce and service websites differently.

Aspect eCommerce Websites Service Websites
Volume of Pages High number of product pages, frequent updates Typically, fewer pages, focused on service info
Impact of Errors 404 or 500 on product pages hurt conversions directly Errors may affect trust but less transactional
Redirect Strategy Must carefully redirect removed products or variants More flexibility, can redirect to service pages
Crawl Budget Importance Critical due to large number of pages Important but usually fewer pages to crawl
Error Monitoring Frequency Requires frequent and automated scans Can rely on manual/checklist-based audits
User Trust Impact High; broken product pages lead to lost sales Moderate; errors reduce perceived professionalism

Identification

Before you can fix page errors, you need to know exactly where and what they are.

I have been in the SEO industry for over 20 years and these are the only and the best free/freemium tools, I use.

  • Use Google Search Console (Coverage & Indexing Reports): Free tool. Shows all applicable status codes, crawl issues and indexing drops so you can identify errors directly from Google’s perspective.

image showing different page errors during indexing as shown in Google Search Console

Image Credit: SE Ranking

  • Use Bing Webmaster Tools: Free tool. Does not directly report pages like GSC but use a combination of Site Scan along with Site Explorer within BWT to find them.

Image of a sample Site Scan in Bing Webmaster Tools

Image showing a sample Site Explorer in Bing Webmaster Tools

Image Credit: Microsoft

  • Run Crawls with Screaming Frog: Freemium tool. Helps detect broken links, redirect chains, incorrect status codes and technical issues before Google finds them. I have been using Screaming Frog for over 10 years now.
  • Analyse Traffic & Exit Pages in Analytics: Sudden drops, high exits or engagement declines often signal hidden errors affecting user experience or indexing.
  • Monitor Server Logs for Error Spikes: Reveals repeated 500/503 errors, blocked bot requests, slow responses and crawling anomalies at the server level.
  • Set Up Automated Alerts & Monitoring Tools: Uptime and real-time monitoring tools warn you instantly about downtime, spikes in errors or performance issues.

I have covered both GSC, BWT & Microsoft Clarity extensively in many of my past webinars.

Step-by-Step Fixes

Once you’ve identified page errors across your site, the next critical step is systematic resolution. Here’s how to fix page errors:

Step 1: Crawl Your Site and Subdomains

Identify all 4xx and 5xx errors across important pages, internal links, and redirects.

Step 2: Categorise

Prioritise by critical pages (money pages, high traffic, backlinks), internal link errors, redirect chains, and server failures.

Step 3: Fix Root Causes

  • Redirect using single-step 301s (keep an internal doc and remove all redirects after they have aged one year)
  • Resolve server and permission issues with logs and hosting support
  • Rebuild or redirect missing pages
  • Use proper 503 codes with “Retry-After” for planned downtime
  • If you must have 404, don’t leave money on the table, make it an exceptional experience for your users, see this.

Step 4: Revalidate in Google Search Console

Request indexing on fixed URLs to speed up re-crawling and re-indexing. Or use URL Inspection tool in both GSC and BWT.

Step 5: Monitor Regularly

Set weekly crawls and monthly audits to maintain uptime and fix new errors promptly.

Conclusion

Page errors are unavoidable, but a well-maintained site will catch and fix them before they harm rankings.

Handled properly, HTTP errors can even help Google understand your site structure. Handled poorly, they can tank visibility, eat crawl budget, and break user trust.

The key is not perfection—it’s proactive monitoring, proper redirects, clean architecture, and stable hosting.

Warning: if you are a nerd like me, you can also setup a Cloudflare Worker to monitor your website and report back, every time users and bots see an error code you nominate (use wildcards over individual codes). If you are unsure how to do this, hit me on LinkedIn.

FAQs

Are all 404 errors harmful for SEO?

Some 404s are normal, but excessive or on important pages harm SEO. Fix critical 404s with redirects or recreate pages. If you must have them, make them exceptional. No web site is perfect and Google understands this, identify, fix, monitor.

How long does it take to recover SEO after fixing errors?

Recovery depends on crawl frequency. Requesting re-indexing speeds the process but expect weeks for full impact. From my personal experience, GSC Pages report takes forever to update. If you have applied the fix, now is the time to wait.

Can 503 errors during maintenance hurt rankings?

Temporary 503s with proper headers are fine, but extended downtime causes ranking drops.

How often should I audit for page errors?

Weekly crawls and monthly deep audits balance maintenance and resource use effectively.

Should eCommerce sites deploy stricter error controls than service sites?

Yes, eCommerce sites rely heavily on product pages, so they need stricter and more frequent monitoring and fixing.